Sister blog of Physicists of the Caribbean in which I babble about non-astronomy stuff, because everyone needs a hobby

Wednesday 20 June 2018

America's Big Society

My hypothesis is that Americans who hate big government do so not because big government is inherently evil, but simply because it genuinely doesn't work in America - perhaps in part (but only in part) as a result of certain elements doing their damnedest to break it.

[I should clarify. I definitely don't mean to suggest that it doesn't work in other countries, because it very much does. I don't even want to say that it's wholly useless in America, because it isn't. What I mean to say is that there's clearly some level on which big government does fail in America, at which it appears incapable of taking even the most basic actions or of making the simplest choices, which does not happen in other countries.]

As the country continues its long recovery from recession, there are signs that a much deeper shift is happening at a local level, the seeds of which were sown years ago. Indicators far more subtle than job numbers suggest a flourishing of entrepreneurship, collaboration and problem-solving, away from the gaze of national media.

After five years spent visiting dozens of towns, The Atlantic writer James Fallows and his wife Deborah have written a book Our Towns which paints a portrait of renewal, a story at odds with the well-documented gridlock of higher levels of government. Fallows says that in several areas - civic engagement, returning talent, growth of tech start-ups, downtown revitalisation, an openness to immigrants and thriving libraries - local America seems to be flourishing.

He's not alone. Another book called The New Localism says a growing number of US cities are addressing the problems of post-industrial America in increasingly imaginative and flexible ways - succeeding where bigger government fails. There is also optimism from the world of tech. After visiting communities in the heart of the country, in a huge drive to help entrepreneurs, internet pioneer Steve Case, co-founder of AOL, says the future looks bright. "I believe that we are entering the Third Wave of the internet, a period in which entrepreneurs will leverage technology to revolutionise major sectors of the economy - healthcare, financial services, agriculture and others," he says.

How cities are rolling up their sleeves and getting things done is the subject of New Localism, a book co-authored by Bruce Katz of the Brookings Institution. "For the past 40 years, we have seen an evolution of urban problem-solving that's becoming more sophisticated and more impactful with every passing year," he says. This "localism" first emerged in the 1980s, he says, when cities began to realise that the "cavalry wasn't coming" from federal and state government, and they were going to have to tackle their problems on their own. City leaders are discovering that problem-solving from the bottom up - in partnerships with others from the worlds of business, technology and education - is more democratic and effective, says Katz.
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-44349211

6 comments:

  1. This is exactly the conclusion I’m slowly and painfully coming to: I’m a big fan of government as a means for supplying basic necessities to society (like healthcare, safe policing etc) but the US congress and executive arm has been a nest of pirates for as long as I can remember. So my view is slowly pivoting away from “you know, electric power’s a good thing” to “who gave that monkey the electric cable?”

    ReplyDelete
  2. David Brin has long advocated that the bleak, near-dystopian representation of America by conservative politicians is dramatically at odds with the reality. But this is a bit of optimism not even he has highlighted heretofore (to my knowledge, anyway).

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh FFS. Big government works just fine in america. Big government is how every US citizen over 65 gets medical care. No sane insurance company would insure the aged for any reasonable price. Big government also delivers granny her Social Security check, brings water to 10k's of farms, & builds the interstate highway system that provides transportation for our food & goods.

    The problem is right wing propaganda has been spouting bullshit about big government for 50 years because they don't like Federal Laws. Like the federal laws that cleaned up pollution, make workplaces safer, & limit racial discrimination.

    ReplyDelete
  4. John Poteet Correct me if I'm wrong (I might well be) but aren't those issues dealt with by the equivalent of a civil service rather than the elected government ?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Rhys Taylor Elected officials are the people who effectively hire the civil servants, provide for their budgets via legislation, & provide oversight & guidance via more legislation. "Big government" is just people like my sister who does salmon stream restoration on California's North Coast.

    That's all it is: a bunch of people doing a lot of different jobs that legislators decided needed doing. Like weather reporting: every weather report on the North American Continent starts out as a data stream from NOAA satellites & weather stations.

    The people at Weather.com, Wunderground, & local TV weather clones can't do jack shit if their NOAA data feed goes down. They're reduced to looking out the window. None of them alone could have funded the billions spent on dozens of weather satellites.

    noaa.gov - Weather forecast tools and resources | National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

    ReplyDelete
  6. They clearly didn't come to any of the places I've lived since the recession.

    ReplyDelete

Due to a small but consistent influx of spam, comments will now be checked before publishing. Only egregious spam/illegal/racist crap will be disapproved, everything else will be published.

Review : Ordinary Men

As promised last time  I'm going to do a more thorough review of Christopher Browning's Ordinary Men . I already mentioned the Netf...