Sister blog of Physicists of the Caribbean in which I babble about non-astronomy stuff, because everyone needs a hobby

Monday, 16 November 2026

Review : The Sea-King and the Sorceress (II)

Welcome back to my look at Neil Price's The Sea-King And The Sorceress. Last time I covered some of the most alien aspects of Viking culture : the ship-burials involving the mass graves of humans and animals, sometimes involving extreme violence and terror. In this concluding part, I want to present some more familiar, even admirable, tendencies. But this, we'll see, is essentially an exception which proves the rule. In examining their attributes which feel most familiar – animal rights, feminist tendencies, trans-acceptance, racial toleration – we have to add serious qualifiers, without which we'd be disguising some of their strangest and wildest characteristics.


2) Inclusivity

In some ways, the Vikings were considerably more tolerant of other people and ideas than we are. Just because they sacrificed people to their gods didn't mean they were doing it because they didn't like them (though slaves do seem to have been used as god-fodder in burials rather than than free peoples). Society was hierarchical, but it doesn't seem to have been a caste system. You could climb the social ladder through achievement, but you'd definitely have to do the climbing yourself. Nobody would appoint you to any role just because you were qualified. And some of their views on social structure stemmed directly on their conception of how the universe worked.


Warrior Women

Let's start with something more straightforward : shield maidens. The women found in the Oseberg ship were almost certainly not warriors themselves, based on the total lack of weapons included in the otherwise-extensive grave goods. The ship itself may have been a repurposed warship, and the eldest woman likely a queen. But there's no hint that they themselves were ever in combat.

Another burial couldn't scream SHIELD MAIDEN !!!! any louder if you gave it a megaphone and a battle horn. Price describes quite nicely the pushback that this generated in some quarters, with due skepticism becoming untenable denialism when you look at just how fucking obvious this is. Was this person a warrior ? Well, she had a sword inlaid with silver, a long knife, a war axe, a bow with a quiver of arrows, two lances, a shield and a helmet. Oh, and she was buried with a horse... outside the gate to a fortress. Near to a barracks.

Honestly I don't know what more you could want, save a runic inscription saying, "I'm a warrior and I killed people", like the, "this is a hammer" label that Eleanor Barraclough described on an ornamental hammer. And Price mentions here that there are also literary descriptions of shield maidens. Some are fantastical, but not all : some are external histories mentioning "and there were women in their ranks" in a very matter-of-fact style that suggests honest reporting, with no obvious motivation for lying. 

Elsewhere, what's harder to square with this is that Viking society had strict gender roles. You could divorce your wife for wearing trousers, and men were not allowed to do women's work (such as sorcery). It would be nice if we could say something simple like "you couldn't pretend to be a different gender", which seems broadly the case but comes with a legion of caveats : people most certainly did do this, just as while war seems to have been viewed primarily as masculine, at least some women got away with stabbing people with swords* just as some men got away with practicing female magic. Emphasis on "some", mind you, as if the numbers of warrior women had been comparable to men, we can be pretty sure that more outside observers would have remarked on this rather more loudly.

* Admittedly, the fact she's got a sword is going to make winning the argument very difficult.

Price also notes that we can't be certain this genetically-female person would actually identify as a woman. I have to admit, with a betrayal of my lefty-liberal principles, to a certain sense of exasperation here... until I realised there's extraordinarily good circumstantial evidence to take this possibility very seriously. 


Shapeshifting and Sorcery

The question that made me think that actually the notion of transgender Vikings is a perfectly respectable one is simple. If you genuinely believe your neighbour can turn into a wolf, why wouldn't you accept that a man could become a woman ?

And there is good evidence that they really did believe in this kind of blurring of the boundaries between human and animal. Sometimes this could be purely a spiritual sort of transformation, with the famous berserkers embodying the predatory nature of wolves and bears rather than ever believed to literally change their bodies. Price notes that even this is relatively unusual, with most cultures who adopt predators as their sigil identifying some noble quality of the animal. The Vikings adopted the violent, uncontrollable predatory urges wholesale and unapologetically.

From adopting a mental aspect, with berserkers being thought to literally lose their minds, it seems a short step to physical transformation. Yet stories of actually changing bodies, are rare – except among the gods, where it was common (Loki even turns into a female horse and becomes pregnant); among the Sámi (on whom more below) shapeshifting tales are more frequent, including even into whales.

Even if a belief in being able to grow claws and fur was relatively uncommon, the belief in adopting the mental aspect of an animal points to something extraordinarily strange :

In the modern West, ever since the Enlightenment, the skin has been the barrier of the person, at least when alive – but the Norse saw things very differently. In the Icelandic sources we meet animals possessed of something other about them, with human eyes and a sense of unease, sometimes also of threat. On occasion, individuals take on another person's appearance. But not everyone, and only at certain times even for the few.

It can be disconcerting to consider all this today. If you believe – in fact, know – that a woman on the neighbouring farm can become a big cat under certain circumstances, but you yourself cannot, then what is the difference between you ? It is surely much more fundamental, another conception of reality itself, or at least implying a much broader sense of self. It will be obvious that (to put it mildly) this Norse understanding of what it was to be a human being would have been both alien and frightening to the majority of their Christian neighbours.

Faced with beliefs like this, the prospect that a man could become a woman seems utterly insignificant. You'd have to be a bit mad to claim that the Vikings had no problem in believing that changing species – even just at the level of the mental attributes –  was a known quantity but gender swapping was unthinkable. And believing that your neighbours were, in some sense, divine, well that must surely make keeping up with the Joneses quite the challenge. 

Or perhaps they didn't see it as divine. The Sámi actually practised ritual burials of bears, treating them as a kind of person : not human, to be sure, but thinking persons. Bizarrely, they believed they could understand human speech (and even breed with people !) and yet as long as the proper rites were observed, it was okay to eat them. Which is an awfully tough mentality to understand. 

Still, the possibility of a literal human-animal continuity, absorbed from the Sámi shamanism into Norse belief (which Price explores more more in The Viking Way) might go some way to explaining how you could coexist with your shapeshifting neighbours. The world would seem very much more alive; in a sense, everything would be seen as magical, rather than people who could shapeshift seen as special orders of being.

And yet a paradox remains. How could gender boundaries be at once so fluid yet apparently rigidly enforced ? More generally, how could the rules be so strict when any boundary appeared as little more than a rough guideline ?

Price suggests some answers in the chapter on the sorceress. The particular burial he considers here dates from c.980 AD in Denmark, a high-status grave containing various magical items including two staffs (Price has done a lot of work demonstrating that these are likely magical rather than functional, again discussed at length in TVW). He suggests a possible association with weaving, associated with fate as in the mythical Norns, and thereby primarily a female activity; there are also more erotic interpretations of witches staffs and brooms. Men were forbidden from such magic, yet undeniably did practice it – including Odin himself.

Price has a couple of possible resolutions to the paradox. Maybe those involved in magic were seen as having a special, third gender, where ordinary social rules did not apply. Or maybe changing gender wasn't the problem, but rather being misgendered : you could be one or the other, with the presence or lack of dangly bits being somewhat incidental, but you couldn't claim to be a man doing woman's magic or claim to be a woman waging war*.

* Emily Southon also notes that early Christian women would claim to have become men, in a sort of sense of spiritual elevation rather than because they had some weird form of spiritual penis envy. The patriarchy runs deep.

Well, maybe. Fascinatingly, we'll probably never really know.


There's No Need To Be Rude

If Viking ideas of gender and humanity were rooted in a deeply different conception of reality, then their apparent racial tolerance also seems paradoxical to modern eyes. These are people the modern far right have adopted as symbols of white power, seeing in the image of the bloodthirsty lunatics something to aspire to on account of their tiny micorpenises. And yet while they did ravage Europe and beyond, splitting skulls and enslaving thousands, there doesn't seem to be much evidence that they did this out of racism. There may well have been a reactionary religious element to some of it, deliberately making war against the encroaching Christians, but skin colour appears to have not been much of a factor.

The Sámi provide another link here. One burial Price describes has a Sámi boat but Nordic weapons, and boat burial itself is much more a Norse tradition than a Sámi one. Clearly there was some level of cultural exchange here, and it can hardly have been all one-way or all hostile. The Vikings, perhaps, were happy to swipe your stuff and burn your house down as soon as look at you, but they'd at least do that indiscriminately. They wouldn't set out to pillage any one particular group. They'd target everyone, and by the same token, it seems that anyone could become a Viking.

In some cases, they'd even try and sleep their way to the top. One ambassador from Islamic Spain had to be warned off from being too familiar with the queen, which points towards the ultimate form of cultural interchange. Other envoys might have reported that the Norse were filthy and terribly singers, but didn't ever suggest that they themselves were badly treated. 

While the Vikings are famous for promoting a highly aggressive form of emigration, less well known is the immigration back to Scandinavia that followed. The slavery aspect of this was, obviously, equally aggressive. But not everyone went unwillingly, and even when they did, it appears far more clearly in the textual sources that it was the stigma of slavery that persisted, not differences in skin colour. There are even indications of Persian ancestry in the Oseberg ship burial, one of the most high-status Scandinavian burials ever uncovered. 

It's probably going too far to suggest that the Nordic lands were a cosmopolitan melting-point of different peoples living happily alongside one another when they weren't having their guts ripped out for human sacrifice. While Price points out that the racial overtones which do exist in the texts come from later sources, I think it's highly unlikely that nobody in Scandinavia ever made fun of the obvious visible differences in the newcomers. What seems more plausible is that racial differences weren't a major driving force of the raids or slaving. And again, if you believe in a human-animal continuity, and a world where people could change into (potentially) whales, why would it matter if they were a slightly different colour ? You might remark on it, certainly. But it would seem strange if most people ever got so obsessively hung up on it in the way that later become so tragically common in the West.


Conclusions

The Viking world was not ours. They lived shorter, more dangerous lives, even among those – and this was actually most of them – who weren't career raiders. They hunted huge bears under the northern lights. They went out stealing other people's stuff as a way of life and a rite of passage. They endured the most awful hardships at sea only to inflict worse hardships on those they met. They hung people in trees and killed horses by the dozen atop ships which they then buried. They had a real fear of the undead and also despised women for wearing trousers. They believed in spiritual and physical transformations, and the boundaries between human and animal, living and the dead, man and woman, were at best highly complex.

And yet... they also loved games and poetry. At least one Islamic source has the supposedly-illiterate Vikings able to debate on equal footing with their own scholars. They'd get involved in petty legal disputes, make silly jokes, get married, get divorced, and do silly Christmas dances in far-off lands when they weren't out splitting skulls. Women could be warriors, gender boundaries were fluid, and they appear to have had little racial motivations in anything they did. Quite plausibly, they'd find modern White Power loonies as pathetic as the rest of us do. They could be motivated by entirely different supernatural beliefs, yet at least one saga has its protagonist converting to atheism. 

To try and enter the mindset of the times is an extraordinary challenge. To try and draw parallels with modern society is a mistake; the lines drawn should actually be extremely wibbly-wobbly and extremely blurry. There are more than a few glimpses of the tantalisingly familiar, echoes of a common humanity that bridges the gulf of centuries, all the while embedded in a world that can feel utterly alien. They are seriously weird, appealing, repulsive all at once. I can't think of anything more compelling than a mixture like that.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Due to a small but consistent influx of spam, comments will now be checked before publishing. Only egregious spam/illegal/racist crap will be disapproved, everything else will be published.

Review : The Sea-King and the Sorceress (II)

Welcome back to my look at Neil Price's The Sea-King And The Sorceress . Last time I covered some of the most alien aspects of Viking c...