“If Earth life cannot thrive on Mars, we don’t need any special cleaning protocol for our spacecraft; and if Earth life actually can survive on Mars, it most likely already does, after four billion years of meteoritic transport and four decades of spacecraft investigations not always following sterilization procedures.”
Originally shared by Universe Today
The recent announcement by NASA confirming the presence of liquid water on Mars pulls planetary protection into the spotlight and is causing some serious head-scratching in the scientific community. On the one hand, having existing liquid water on the Red…
http://www.universetoday.com/123029/the-puzzle-of-planetary-protection/
Sister blog of Physicists of the Caribbean in which I babble about non-astronomy stuff, because everyone needs a hobby
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
It's okay to like vinyl
Here's a nice if somewhat over-lengthy piece about why people prefer antiquated technologies like vinyl records instead of digital medi...
-
This is nice video which attempts to solve why the world is sometimes such a crappy place and obvious solutions don't get implemented. I...
-
"To claim that you are being discriminated against because you have lost your right to discriminate against others shows a gross lack o...
-
Three rules for any article on AI : 1) AI does not yet have the the same kind of understanding as human intelligence. 2) There is no guar...
Meteoritic transport is a one-way street from the discussions I've seen - you shouldn't get Earth meteorites on Mars, so no contamination by that route.
ReplyDeleteFrom this angle, "planetary protection" is a bunch of polito-religious BS. A planet can take care of itself. A few microbes aren't going to hurt anything.
ReplyDeleteThey would make it harder to spot Martian microbes though.
ReplyDeleteYou have a point, but does it matter? I think the most important thing is to learn about microbes not seen on Earth and what affects they might have on us.
ReplyDeleteWe could probably tell the difference between Martian and Earth microbes with a fully-equipped lab, but not necessarily with the limited equipment on a rover. So in that sense maybe "planetary protection" is pointless for a sample return mission, but essential for one-way missions. I'm just guessing though.
ReplyDelete